|
By Lisa Wangsness, Globe Staff
November 24, 2005
Tucked into the corner of a quiet plaza between the
State House and City Hall, the Garden of Peace was meant to be a
haven for families of homicide victims, a place to reflect on the
loved ones memorialized there. Since the garden's dedication last
year, families have come from across Massachusetts to sit among
the river rocks, carved with some 500 names of murder victims, and
mourn their loss.
So it came as an unpleasant surprise to the garden's founders when
they learned that Suffolk University is considering a plan to turn
a nearby nine-story state-owned office building into a 31-story
tower that would house a 792-bed dormitory and student center.
Evelyn Tobin, a cofounder of the garden, said that adding a dormitory
with hundreds of students passing through each day would wreck the
atmosphere of the memorial they worked for years to build, and that
many consider a special place.
''This is totally not compatible with the spirit of the garden,"
said Tobin, whose daughter was stabbed to death in Lexington in
1992 by an unknown assailant.
Suffolk University officials say they have met with representatives
from the Garden of Peace to discuss their concerns. But they say
that adding dormitory space would alleviate the pressure on the
housing market in a city where universities abound and student housing
is scarce.
Mayor Thomas M. Menino and other Boston officials have spent years
badgering universities to add dormitories to free up housing for
residents. Though many institutions have responded, adding more
than 6,000 beds between 1998 and 2004, unmet demand for dormitory
space in the city could be as high as 17,200 beds, according to
a Boston Redevelopment Authority study published last year.
Suffolk's initial proposal for the project would roughly double
the number of dormitory beds the university has for its 4,300 Boston
undergrads, said Pat Meservey, the university's provost and academic
vice president.
''We have limited housing for our students at this point, and we
feel that it is in both the students' and the city's best interest
to increase the number of beds we have available," Meservey
said.
After a competitive bidding process last spring, the state chose
Suffolk's proposal to redevelop 20 Somerset St., which until last
year housed the Metropolitan District Commission. The development
team is now conducting engineering studies to determine whether
its plans would be feasible for the site. The scale of the tower
project, which would cost more than $100 million, remains uncertain
and would take several years to complete, Meservey said.
If a sale goes through in January, the university would still have
to secure approvals from the BRA, which will include opportunities
for public input.
Molly Sherden, vice president of government affairs for the Beacon
Hill Civic Association, said that she had not seen plans for the
project, but that she is concerned that it could threaten the Garden
of Peace. ''I know how valuable memorials are to people who have
lost loved ones for different reasons, and as I understand the project
currently, I think it would have a very significant negative impact
on the Garden of Peace," Sherden said.
A decade in the planning, the garden is on state land set aside
through legislation during the redevelopment of 100 Cambridge Street,
formerly the Saltonstall building, a state office building plagued
by environmental problems, Tobin said.
Families of homicide victims who have a connection to Massachusetts
can request to have their loved one's name inscribed on one of more
than 1,000 river rocks that together represent a dry riverbed; among
them are John F. Kennedy and Robert F. Kennedy. At one end of the
riverbed is a symbol of hope and rebirth: a cast bronze sculpture
of three ibis soaring skyward by Judy Kensley McKie, whose son was
stabbed to death in Cambridge in 1990.
Tobin said that she and others involved with the garden understand
the need for dormitories in Boston and have nothing against college
students. But she said they believe that the Suffolk project ought
to be located somewhere else and not only because of the noise and
hubbub it could create. The tower's landscape architect, she said,
believes that the structure could create wind effects and cast shadows
that would harm the garden's vegetation.
''They were very polite, but they gave us really no assurances
that we would have any input at all into the plan that they have,"
she said.
Meservey said the university would take every precaution to mitigate
the proposed tower's effect on the garden, including locating the
entrance on the opposite side of the building to limit student traffic
and offering landscaping to shelter it.
  
|